Saturday, February 8, 2025

Kylian Mbappe’s selfish Ballon d’Or bid could backfire badly: France superstar only wants to play ‘important’ games for his country

Share

The striker reportedly only wants to play in big games for his country, but that sort of selfish decision has the potential to backfire massively

So, Kylian Mbappe has taken a stand. Last weekend it was reported that the France and Real Madrid forward only wants to play in the games that really matter for his country. According to French outlet Foot Mercato, Mbappe “would ideally only like to play important matches with the French team.”

It was news that was met with a mixture of puzzlement and indignation around the world. How could this player, France’s captain, Madrid’s newest Galactico, one of the most recognisable athletes on the planet, elect to not do what he’s very good at? Well, it turns out there’s some complexity here. The report suggests that the reason for Mbappe’s decision is his desire to win a coveted Ballon d’Or, a prize he will no doubt have to fight Madrid team-mates for.

But there are perhaps other reasons at play here, too. Player welfare is a concern, as is the fear of injury. But for all of the reasons that it might just make sense, Mbappe’s reported decision to sit himself out when he pleases could prove to be detrimental. A megastar, a captain and a leader is doing something not only inherently selfish, but also something that could harm his team. Mbappe’s Ballon d’Or bid by omission could backfire badly.

Too many matches

Kylian Mbappe PSG Clermont Ligue 1

Mbappe’s reasoning is said to be simple: he is playing too many games. Some of them are not helping his case to win the Ballon d’Or. It is irrelevant to Mbappe the brand – not the footballer – to stroll through an hour of an ugly international in the Nations League. The virtuosic talent, we are perhaps implicitly told, can only deliver so often.

And in some ways, that makes sense. Squad rotation is a normal part of football these days. The best teams, typically, are the ones who can reach into their bench and find answers. They can cope without their best players, and manage the knocks that come over the course of the season. That certainly wasn’t the case for Mbappe’s PSG. When he was out injured, or benched in his latter days in Paris, PSG struggled to pick up points. No matter how much Luis Enrique insisted that he was making the best decisions for his team.

It is hardly revolutionary to suggest that teams tend to need their best player to win, but the absolute best can at least manage when those individuals need a night off.

Injury fears growing

Manchester City FC v Arsenal FC - Premier League

That concern is of particular note after the events of recent weeks. This can all be traced back to mid-September, when Rodri – Man City’s star defensive midfielder – claimed that players would be willing to go on strike in order to protest against fixture congestion. Cruelly, he tore his ACL a week later. Dani Carvajal made a similar claim in a press conference – only to see his season ended in similarly unfortunate circumstances.

It’s a reasonable claim from the players. Some individuals could play upwards of 80 games this year, when leagues, cups, the oft-crticised Club World Cup and international games are factored in. Rodri claimed that the optimum number of games to play over a season is “between 40-50.” Some players could get close to double that.

It seems real action is being taken to that effect. FIFPro, the worldwide representative organisation for professional footballers, filed a complaint Monday evening over “abusive and anti-competitive” acts. How, exactly, this all ends, isn’t quite clear. But the sentiment is out there. In some ways, Mbappe is serving as an extension of that.

The Ballon d’Or pull

Emi Martinez Kylian Mbappe Ballon d'Or ceremony

This is, we are led to believe, is all focused around Mbappe’s supposed desire to win the Ballon d’Or. Whatever importance you attach to the award, there is no doubt that winning it remains a huge ambition for the Frenchman and the world’s top players. After all, in the post-Lionel Messi and Cristiano Ronaldo wasteland, the battle to finish first appears to be more wide open than ever.

This year, Vinicius Jr seems the obvious winner. His trophy cabinet speaks for itself, as does his penchant for scoring important goals. Want the big player, for the big moments, with the most style? Vinicius is your man.

Mbappe, though, might claim to be more talented. He is certainly a more consistent goalscoring threat, and has won everything but the Champions League. Throw in that he is still just 25 and it would seem that there is a Ballon d’Or in his future. But Mbappe feels, of course, that he can influence his chances. Play in the big moments, score the right goals, show up when it really counts and he may just pip his Madrid team-mate to the award next year. And there is some sense to that. If individual accolades are what this is all about, then Mbappe is, in effect, making the right decision.

France will be fine – for now

Griezmann Mbappe France Euro 2024

But it’s not that simple. In fact, his absence could be costly.

His concerns with France, of course, really depend on what Mbappe defines as “important” games. It would make sense, broadly, that he has no interest in playing for Les Bleus in the Nations League. It is rare than anyone learns much from these games; even fixtures against the likes of Belgium and Italy would seem skippable.

Furthermore, France are blessed with such great depth that even Mbappe’s absence is unlikely to have a seismic effect. Even though they have lost a certain edge with the retirements of Antoine Griezmann and Olivier Giroud, Didier Deschamps can call on the likes of Randal Kolo Muani, Ousmane Dembele, Bradley Barcola, Michael Olise, Marcus Thuram and Christopher Nkunku in attack. They will still win games.

But, more broadly, there are issues over compatibility. What kind of message does it send if the captain of your country isn’t willing to lace up his boots for the games he deems unnecessary? And when it comes to the really difficult ones – tournament play and all – then there is certainly something to be said for a lack of chemistry in the frontline. They will probably be fine in the interim. But Mbappe could cause disruption with his absence – or even his return.

Trouble in Madrid

Kylian Mbappe Real Madrid 2024-25

The more pertinent issue here may well be for his club. Real Madrid haven’t exactly started the season poorly – they are undefeated after nine games and trail Barcelona by three points. But they haven’t run away with the league like many thought they would. Indeed, although it would be impossible to achieve the kind of breathing room needed to win the title after just nine games, that Barca are top of the table is a real surprise.

Suddenly, something resembling a title race is forming. Madrid, of course, won’t worry too much about this. Such is the mentality of the club that they probably know that their best football won’t be played until April. In other words: talk to us in the spring.

Still, those pesky midweek games, the ugly away fixtures, are now more important than they ever have been. With Barca winning eight of nine, and a Clasico on the horizon, Madrid might find themselves six points back after 11 games. Some teams don’t recover from that kind of deficit – especially if their form is going the wrong way.

There are also the complications of a new Champions League format. In previous years, a team could win their group by matchday four. Pick up four wins on the trot, and you can cruise through the rest of the group stage. But now, an expanded league phase puts more emphasis on every fixture. And given Madrid have already lost to Lille – a game they were expected to win – they might have to play an extra preliminary knockout tie. Piece it all together and Mbappe could be forced to play in the sort of fixtures he wants to avoid for his country.

Personal glory over team success?

Kylian-Mbappe

The problem with all of this remains, of course, that Ballon d’Or wins depend largely on team triumphs. Mbappe may finish as top scorer in La Liga, or smash records for his country in limited minutes, but it’s trophies – and the impact that an individual has on winning them – that voters tend to factor in when it comes to the Ballon d’Or.

And therein lies the contradiction of this whole thing. Mbappe wants to win the Ballon d’Or, an individualistic pursuit of an award. However, his team really needs to succeed for him to be in the running for it. If it turns out that he wants to rest for some lesser club games too and Madrid aren’t as good without him, then how is he supposed to win the personal prize he covets so dearly?

Those two ideas would seem to be at conflict with each other, Mbappe sacrificing his club for self-interest – all while failing to achieve the goal that this is supposedly all about. He may be the best player in the world, but this singular, selfish act could well end up being detrimental to all parties.

Read more

Local News